DOI: https://doi.org/10.65969/CMA_35-2_74.76
Keywords: Fiscal Consolidation Limits, Structural Tax Inefficiency, Energy Circular Debt
This article evaluates Pakistan’s fiscal structure questioning whether recent improvements in fiscal and primary balances are authentic reforms or merely temporary fixes. It reveals that while the fiscal deficit has decreased and a positive primary balance appeared, these changes stem from short-term measures like expenditure cuts rather than genuine structural reforms. The article discusses persistent losses in State-Owned Enterprises, inefficiencies in the energy sector, substantial tax expenditures, and weak governance, which threaten fiscal sustainability. Despite a significant increase in tax collection, high borrowing needs and a growing debt servicing burden severely limiting fiscal space for development. The dependency on IMF programs is critiqued for providing only temporary stabilization without addressing core structural issues, like the narrow tax base and inefficient spending. The tax system is described as narrow, heavily reliant on withholding taxes, and characterized by large tax expenditures. Structural problems from the 18th Amendment exacerbate fiscal imbalances. The article reviews the proposed National Fiscal Pact as a potential reform, emphasizing that sustainable fiscal stability requires comprehensive reforms in expenditure management, energy restructuring, broadening the tax base, and improving fiscal federal coordination.